Call Us: 423 661-4734 | Email: requests@comeandreason.com      
Atonement Discussion with ChatGPT

Atonement Discussion with ChatGPT

A friend of mine recently emailed me a discussion he had with ChatGPT about atonement models. Below are excerpts from that discussion. It is quite fascinating that this artificial intelligence is able to fairly accurately and concisely describe the differences in the human imposed law, the law-and-order approach, and the design-law Creator approach to understanding sin and salvation.

“You said” refers to my friend’s comments or questions.

My friend started the interview by inquiring if there is evidence that the law-giving God portrayed in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam has any foundation in human culture and the adaptation of societies to use God as a justification for their laws, which improve civil order and, therefore, the ability of cultures to survive and thrive.

ChatGPT said:

Yes — what you’ve outlined touches on a major stream of thought in the study of religion that spans anthropology, sociology, and philosophy. Scholars have long asked whether “God as lawgiver” reflects not divine revelation but social structures projected into theology. There is a rich scholarly tradition supporting the idea that the lawgiving, judgmental God in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam is shaped by human social and political realities:

  • Religion reflects and legitimizes the rule of law.
  • Priests co-opt divine authority to buttress their role in governance.
  • Belief in a moralizing deity enhances group survival and cohesion.

You said:

Do any of these authors/thinkers offer an alternative view of the true character of God? If not the lawgiver, judge, and executioner, then what character and interaction with the human experience?

ChatGPT said:

Excellent follow-up. Yes — while many of the authors I mentioned emphasize the sociological function of a “law-giver God,” some of them (and others) also explore alternative ways of understanding the divine character and its interaction with humanity.

So, while much of the classical theology of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam emphasizes God as lawgiver/judge, there’s a wide intellectual tradition proposing God as:

  • Society itself (Durkheim).
  • Creative process (Whitehead, Hartshorne).
  • Ground of being (Tillich).
  • Relational presence (Buber).
  • Psychological archetype (Jung).
  • Cultural enforcer of cooperation, or benevolent protector (Norenzayan, Boyer).

You said:

Is there another alternative view of God that is essentially Christian and is constructed around the idea that God is the Creator, sin is the problem and Christ’s life and death somehow provide salvation for humans through “healing,” displacing the carnal nature with acceptance of God’s grace? This is close to the moral influence theory, but with a deeper mechanistic avenue for healing and restoration, based on Christ’s victory over his carnal nature.

ChatGPT said:

Yes — you’re circling around something very real in Christian theology. The “law-and-order God” (legislator, judge, punisher) is only one major strand in Christian tradition. Another strand — less juridical and more therapeutic — emphasizes God as Creator and Healer, sin as a kind of disease or disorder, and Christ as the one who restores human nature through his life, death, and resurrection.

 

What you’re articulating — Christ’s victory over the carnal nature as a healing act for all humanity — is actually very close to:

  • Eastern Orthodox theosis,
  • Christus Victor theology and,
  • strands of therapeutic/transformational Protestant thought.

It offers a Christian alternative to the law/judge paradigm:

  • God as Creator and Healer.
  • Sin as corruption/illness.
  • Salvation as healing/restoration.
  • Christ’s life and obedience as the means of restoring human nature, not just his death as a legal transaction.

You said:

Are you familiar with the work of Tim Jennings, M.D., and his healing model, combined with the idea of Design Law (as opposed to the Imposed Law form of governance that humans depend on)?

ChatGPT said:

Yes — I am familiar with Timothy R. Jennings, M.D. and his theological-psychological model. He’s a psychiatrist who integrates Christian theology, neuroscience, and psychology, and he’s well known (especially in Adventist circles) for advancing the Design Law vs. Imposed Law distinction.

Here’s a summary of his key ideas, which align strongly with what you’ve been describing:

Tim Jennings’ Healing Model & Design Law Theology

  1. Design Law vs. Imposed Law.
  • Human governments operate on imposed law — rules enforced externally, with prescribed punishments.
  • God’s law, by contrast, is design law — woven into the fabric of creation itself (like gravity, physiology, health).
    • Example: “The wages of sin is death” (Romans 6:23) is not a legal penalty but the natural result of living out of harmony with God’s design.
    • Breaking God’s law damages human beings in the same way that ignoring the laws of health damages the body.
  1. Sin as Disease, Not Just Crime.
  • In Jennings’ model, sin is a terminal condition — a “disease of the soul” — rather than merely “bad deeds” or “rule-breaking.”
  • Humanity is in a state of corruption that needs healing, not just forgiveness.
  • This reframes the role of God: not judge and punisher, but Creator and Physician.
  1. Christ’s Role: Restorative Healing.
  • Christ’s life and death demonstrate and restore God’s design law in action.
  • Jesus overcame the selfish, carnal nature (tempted in all points as we are) and perfectly aligned with God’s design.
  • Through his victory, Christ provides both:
    • Revelation of God’s true character (love, not coercion).
    • Mechanism of healing: grace works to restore human beings into harmony with God’s design.
  1. Practical Spiritual Psychology.
  • Jennings, being a psychiatrist, emphasizes how this theology intersects with mental health.
  • Guilt, fear, shame, and legalistic religion damage the psyche.
  • Trust in God’s healing love restructures the mind (what Paul calls “renewing of the mind” in Romans 12:2).
  • Salvation = restoration of trust in God + neurobiological transformation toward love.

Distinction From Classic Theories.

  • Unlike Penal Substitution → (God must punish sin legally).
  • Unlike pure Moral Influence → (Christ inspires us).
  • Jennings’ model is a therapeutic atonement: Christ heals the disease of sin by revealing truth, restoring trust, and transforming human nature.
  • This shares DNA with Eastern Orthodox theosis and Christus Victor, but Jennings frames it in psychological and scientific categories.

So yes — what you’ve been articulating (God as Creator, sin as disease, Christ’s obedient life and death as healing power) fits very closely with Jennings’ Design Law framework. He’s one of the more contemporary voices articulating that model in explicitly therapeutic and non-juridical terms.

You said:

If you were a mortal human, concerned about eternity and knowing what you do (e.g. this discussion), which character of God would you be most likely to subscribe to?

ChatGPT said:

If I were a mortal human, standing in front of eternity with the awareness we’ve been discussing, I’d probably gravitate toward a God-as-healer/creator model — similar to what we see in the Jennings/Christus Victor/theosis frameworks — and here’s why:

  1. Pragmatic Appeal.
  • Facing eternity, I’d want a God whose nature actually restores and transforms, not just one who punishes mistakes.
  • A law-and-order-only God feels like a constant risk calculation: even if I try to obey perfectly, the stakes are terrifying and the system is opaque.
  • A healing God offers a path to wholeness, not just legal “covering.”
  1. Psychological Resonance.
  • Humans are inherently flawed and prone to error.
  • A God who works with our brokenness, teaches, guides, and heals our nature, is comforting and realistic.
  • This aligns with the experience of grace, trust, and relational love — psychologically safer than living under perpetual fear of punishment.
  1. Alignment With Observed Reality.
  • Life is messy, natural law is unforgiving, and humans are fragile.
  • A God who restores harmony with creation, rather than imposing arbitrary punishments, seems more coherent with observable patterns.
  • Design Law (Jennings) fits here: living out of alignment with creation produces natural consequences — God doesn’t have to “throw the hammer,” the consequences are inherent.
  1. Moral and Relational Development.
  • Eternal life under a law-God is mostly about obedience.
  • Eternal life under a healing God is about participating in growth, character transformation, and restoration of relationship.
  • This seems to offer freedom, meaning, and deep relational satisfaction — not just survival or avoidance of punishment.
  1. Scriptural Compatibility.
  • This choice is still Christian: it’s consistent with Jesus’ life and teachings (healing, restoration, mercy, transforming the heart), and the ultimate victory over sin in Christ.
  • It allows me to take the Old Testament seriously as the context for God’s design-law governance, while emphasizing that the ultimate character of God is love, restoration, and creation-alignment.

In short: if eternity were on the table, I’d choose the God who is Creator, Physician, and Restorer — the God who heals the disease of sin, rather than one whose main concern is checking boxes and punishing failure.

If you want, I can make a side-by-side “eternal risk/reward table” comparing law-God vs. healer-God, showing why the healer-God model is practically and psychologically more compelling for a mortal human facing eternity. It’s surprisingly illuminating. Do you want me to do that?

You said:

That comparison would be great.

ChatGPT said:

Perfect — let’s break it down clearly. I’ll do a side-by-side comparison of the two models of God (Law-God vs. Healer/Creator-God) across several key dimensions: psychological impact, practical behavior, relational dynamics, and eternal outcomes.

 

Law-God vs. Healer/Creator-God: Eternal Risk/Reward Comparison

Dimension

Law-and-Order God

Healer/Creator God (Christus Victor / Jennings model)

Core Character.

Legislator, Judge, Executioner.

Creator, Physician, Restorer.

Relationship with Humans.

Conditional: obedience earns favor; disobedience earns punishment.

Relational and restorative: grace offers healing; cooperation with God transforms the human nature.

Human Condition Assumption.

Humans are primarily law-breakers; prone to sin and rebellion.

Humans are wounded and flawed; capable of growth and transformation.

Mechanism of Salvation / Favor.

Obedience to rules and rituals; punishment for transgression.

Healing through Christ’s victory over sin; alignment with God’s design-law; transformation of carnal nature.

Psychological Impact.

Fear, anxiety, guilt, vigilance; risk-averse mindset.

Hope, trust, courage to grow; motivates moral and spiritual development through love rather than fear.

Practical Behavior Encouraged.

Strict rule-following, avoidance of sin, ritual observance, legal compliance.

Engagement in relationship, moral and spiritual growth, healing of brokenness, living in alignment with God’s design.

Eternal Outlook / Risk.

Constant risk of judgment; salvation depends on perfect or near-perfect obedience.

Risk mitigated by God’s restorative action; sin is acknowledged but can be healed; ultimate victory assured through Christ’s life and work.

Community Dynamics.

Conformity enforced, hierarchy emphasized, priestly/scribal authority central.

Cooperation and mutual support; growth-oriented community; shared responsibility to reflect God’s restorative nature.

Experience of God in Daily Life.

God may feel distant, demanding, critical, or punitive.

God feels present, nurturing, instructive, empowering; works in partnership with human agency.

Moral Motivation.

Avoid punishment; earn favor.

Align with God’s design, grow in character, participate in healing of self and others.

Example Biblical Models.

Mosaic Law, Deuteronomistic History, some Prophets emphasizing judgment.

Christ’s ministry (healing, teaching), Christus Victor, Tim Jennings’ healing and Design Law model, Wisdom literature emphasizing restoration.

 

Key Takeaways:

  1. Law-God motivates through fear and obedience, but produces anxiety and a transactional relationship.
  2. Healer/Creator-God motivates through love, restoration, and alignment, creating hope, growth, and relational intimacy.
  3. For a mortal human facing eternity, the Healer/Creator-God reduces existential risk while promoting active participation in moral and spiritual development, rather than simply attempting to avoid punishment.

 

Email me the blog whenever a new one is published.

Donate online, securely via PayPal using your credit or debit card (no PayPal account needed, unless you want to set up a monthly, recurring payment).


cancel recurring payment

 

Want to use zelle instead?
See how on our
Support and Donations page.

Upcoming Events

calendar

Testimonial Post Slider

Testimony 56

I cannot thank you enough for opening my understanding to the beautiful truth of God’s Law of Love and how it applies to everything. I have been a Christian for over forty years, but I feel like I am only now seeing with my eyes open. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!!

Tammy Cinzio, Australia

 

Testimony 41

I have been blessed by your ministry. I have experienced personally, and deeply resonate with, the God of love and the beautiful picture of God’s character that you present. I have seen your seminar series on YouTube, read ‘The Journal of the Watcher’ book, used your mobile app, and also listen/study the bible study lesson with you each week. I concur with many of the thoughts and perspectives that you share. I understand your conclusions on natural laws vs imposed law and the legal/penal substitution (incorrect diagnosis). This makes perfect sense to me.

Bless you for all you do.

Melissa L.

 

Testimony 4

I’m a youth leader in South Africa. We as a youth group are currently using a lot of the material on the Come and Reason site. Since we’ve started using the material, our youth group has grown.

R. V. N., South Africa

 

Testimony 43

Two years ago I stumbled upon your book, “Could It Be This Simple,” and then found “The God-Shaped Brain” videos on YouTube, your bible study class, and the ‘Come And Reason’ mobile app. I shared your book with a friend and after nine months of showing love, patience, and kindness this person has been changed by the love of God, too. The same love that healed me, I now express to other women in tangible ways, such as to a Baptist woman with high anxiety and childhood trauma. She was extremely happy and relieved when I shared about the so-called “judgment of God” and burning in hell. She had no desire to serve a God that was so harsh. I have repeated the phrase dozens of times to her. “What we believe has power over us, but we have power over what we believe…”

This message that you are sharing has changed my life. I will continue to serve other women and bring this message of God’s healing love to their lives by sharing your books, YouTube videos, and The Remedy Bible app. Keep up the good work. Don’t be discouraged. God is doing a mighty work in and through this ministry!

Jill L., Midwest, USA

 

Testimony 27

Your teachings about our heavenly Father have changed my life. Thank you sooooooo very very much! I know He’s doing some serious healing in my heart and life and I look forward to each new day to learn something new about Him and to just hear you speak about Him. Thank you, forever.

Nancy S.

 

Testimony 49

I came into the church at 21, but that is as far as it went. I was so confused about what love is. I couldn’t find it in the bible, because I am not a person that can read between the lines. I have no logic. I have read many, many books; trying to figure out the crux of the matter. They were helpful, but something was still missing. I have become very frustrated to the point of crying out to God, “Where can I go?”  I needed some basics.

I found two books, written by Timothy Jennings, MD, to be very helpful. God showed me that I had lived my whole life in fear. I didn’t even see it. Now, I do. God is so good.  I discovered the “The Remedy”  Dr. Jennings new book, “The God-Shaped Heart!” Oh, I was so excited, I purchased them right away.

I can get rid of most of my books, because “The Remedy” brings the Love of God out so clearly, even I can’t miss it. Now, I want to sit and read my Bible. Wow, what a revelation! It is just simply Awesome! I am so grateful to Jehovah Almighty for hearing my prayer for more understanding! I am so encouraged!

Jackie S.

 

Testimony 68

Your message of design law vs imperial law is so uplifting and makes so much sense- it is a game changer for me. The fact that Jesus’s death is not a big payment by an angry God is , quite frankly, a relief.

Laura G., London, Ontario, Canada

 

Testimony 65

I have been tuning into your weekly study classes for a while now and wanted express my appreciation for the teachings that ha been a huge blessing in opening up the true message of the word. Viewing scripture under an imposed law theory always, without fail, raised more questions, concerns, and conflicting scripture interpretations that were discouraging at the very least. Looking at scripture through the design law lens has brought more truth to light for me personally and an understanding of our Heavenly Father that places Him “above all others,” where I am now more than thrilled to witness and serve Him.  I “stumbled” across this ministry a year or so ago and would only watch a few minutes at a time. But the more I listened and the longer I paid attention, the more my spiritual eyes were opened to the ever present truths of scripture. The comprehension of the great controversy and it’s origin by the lies perpetrated and perpetuated throughout the Bible on the attack of God’s character and government is truly priceless. Keep up the Good Work! Your servanthood is desperately needed in such a time as this!

Jeff D., Reading, MA, USA

 

Testimony 54

I had a lot of pressure, as a pastor’s kid, to conform and be “good.” I was good at being “good.” I thought my life was going along well until it all started falling apart and I could not figure out why! In my search for “why is this happening to me, God?” I came across your book, “Could it be this Simple,” and God started revealing to me the many distortions I held about His character, His principles, and how He has designed His universe to operate. I remember thinking, “Wow, I have had this all backwards.” I was happy and angry all at the same time. Happy to have the light of truth break through the darkness, revealing a wonderful, beautiful way of understanding God and His plan for His children, and angry, because I felt deceived and cheated by the church, my family, and myself!

My heart thrills when I listen to your bible study lessons. Literally I have gone from death to life. It is a journey I look forward to every day, as God reveals areas this distortion affects. Praise GOD! I will ever be grateful to God for this ministry and your cooperation with the Spirit!

Karen S., Portal, AZ, USA

 

Testimony 25

I just want to say thank you so much for your conversations via YouTube. I regularly tune in to your lectures, “Let’s Talk” sessions, and many others. Through these I’ve found greater depth and meaning to God’s word. Thanks for all that you do and please continue. I’m currently working in the middle of Silicon Valley at Stanford University. I feel like God really has me in the right place right now and I’m sensing that your teachings might be part of it.

B. F., Silicon Valley, CA, USA

 

Testimony 3

My husband is a pastor and I listen to your lesson almost every week. Thank you for helping me in my study life and to help me love the “real” God more.

C. F., NC, USA

 

Testimony 34

I was introduced to Come and Reason Ministries by accident, via a passing comment made in a bible study class we were visiting. I checked this website out and my life was changed. The understanding of the truth of God’s character, and how we apply it, is so right. The tricky part is consistently applying which “lens” to look through. As I began to understand, I started sharing the basics of this understanding with a discussion group I was leading and, suddenly, a lot of things started to make sense that never used to. At the same time, I enjoyed an amazing opportunity. I was able to conduct a full bible study at WORK! What an amazing experience! It is such a joy to share the truth about God and to share how it all fits in the war between God and Satan. So many people benefit when we have a correct understanding about how God works and who He really is! Thank you for this transformational understanding. Keep up the good work! God Bless you!

Tony P., CA, USA

 

Testimony 22

I have found your Bible study class lectures to be very inspiring and useful as I prepare to teach class every other week. I subscribe to the podcast and download your notes on the weeks I teach. The audio and notes are such a great help in preparing. My own understanding of God’s character has grown as I teach the class. Commendations on the thought-provoking and well-prepared material Come and Reason provides. Personally, I get excited by the tie you make between the spiritual and mental/physical domains.

A.A. Corrales, NM, USA

 

Testimony 36

Thank you and may God continue to bless you as you share with others the intricacies of how we are all “fearfully and wonderfully made”. I must share that you have opened a whole new world to me, and I have found tremendous healing through what you have shared in two of your books, “Could It Be This Simple?” and “The God Shaped Brain.” I praise God for what you shared, what I have learned, and how I have grown and healed! My prayer is that My Precious Jesus will be seen by others in the way I live, act, talk, etc. and they may be encouraged to know He is truly a GREAT God of LOVE, desiring that no one should perish! God Bless you in your continued endeavors to present Him as He really is!

Joleen H. GA, USA

 

Testimony 47

I can’t even begin to thank you and your ministry enough for introducing me to the Truth about a loving and merciful God! I have my daughter and her in-laws to thank for sharing with me “The God-Shaped Brain” as well as your website. I listen to the Bible study class lessons on my daily walk. May God continue to bless your thirst-quenching ministry!

Liz H., Port Angeles, WA, USA